Gini’s Christmas Classics | The Man Who Invented Christmas

The Two Gay Geeks and our Staff are taking a much needed break from Thanksgiving through the end of the year, but we still wanted to have content for you to read during that time. As such we got busy and watched all of our favorite holiday videos. Some are classics and others are off-beat and loosely associated with the holidays. We hope you enjoy our offerings and that you holiday season is safe, sane, and satisfying.

The Man Who Invented Christmas

by Gini Koch

I’m not a huge fan of the Christmas Movie. They tend to be a little schmaltzy, sometimes maudlin, with an emphasis on “the season” that seems more than one holiday can handle. Basically, it’s been a long time since I’ve sat down willingly to watch a specific movie tied to Christmas in more than setting alone.

On the other hand, I’m a gigantic Charles Dickens fan, nay a Dickens fangirl. In addition to loving his work, I also know that he was a hugely influential author in terms of the business of publishing. He was a rock star in his day and is considered the best of the Victorian authors (with good reason). Plus and because of this, almost all of modern publishing owes a great debt to him (royalties, payment per word, advances, copyright protection, serialization of novels, self-publishing…the list goes on, all created or vastly strengthened by Dickens).

However, I don’t love every adaptation of Dickens’ work. And this movie isn’t an adaptation so much as it’s a look into how “A Christmas Carol” came to be. And it’s not really what you expect. Frankly, it’s better. And it proves that Dickens did more than just influence publishing in a big way – he did the same for Christmas.

Charles Dickens (Dan Stevens) is having money issues he doesn’t want to share with his friends and family, he’s had a couple of flop books, and needs another hit in order to keep on paying the bills and feeding his growing family. Oh, and he can’t come up with a new idea for anything. But through a series of experiences, some with his friend and agent John Forster (Justin Edwards), some via the family’s new maid Tara (Anna Murphy), some from dealings with his lawyers or publishers, friends and frenemies, and his own family, he gathers inspiration for a Christmas story.

Through a series of interesting events, Dickens discovers and creates the character of Scrooge (Christopher Plummer) and from then on, Scrooge hangs out in Dickens’ head, arguing with him, helping him, admonishing him, and generally acting like characters in your head do. And as other characters show up, they hang out, too.

As an author, this movie was the most accurate portrayal of what it’s like to BE an author I’ve ever seen. Most “author” movies or TV shows either merely show feverish typing, the crumpling of paper, and utter despair (so that you wonder why anyone would write), or they never show the writer actually writing or creating anything though books somehow magically appear (looking at you, Castle). But The Man Who Invented Christmas embraces what it’s like to be constantly looking for inspiration in terms of names, locations, scenes, etc., and also what it’s like to have people in your head who are, many times, more real to you than the real people around you. (And also what it’s like to be interrupted when you’re in the throes of creativity.)

Dickens is haunted by his past, and also haunted by his living father, John Dickens (Jonathan Pryce), a charming man who’s busy selling his famous son’s autographs and borrowing money using his son’s name behind said son’s back, while also wasting the money said son gives him on things that don’t necessarily matter. Dickens has a lot of resentment for his parents – incredibly well-deserved – that he has to deal with, all while trying to write a and publish a Christmas book in six weeks – so that it can be out before Christmas (yes, essentially, he also created the Christmas retail season). Does he manage it? Well, we know he does, but it’s how he does, and what goes on while he’s doing it, that matters.

At the time Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol, Christmas wasn’t as big a deal as it is now, it was something of a minor holiday. But A Christmas Carol changed all of that. And before you scoff, I’ve done the research (remember, I’m a Dickens fangirl), and this movie was incredibly accurate. There were a few liberties taken, but not all that many, and far less than normal for any kind of biopic. All of the backstory we discover about Dickens and his family is true, as well as his influence on both the Christmas holiday and traditions and, most importantly, charitable giving. A Christmas Carol was directly responsible for a huge increase in charitable giving, and that alone would be enough to call Dickens a reformer. But he was passionate about child labor, how debtors were treated, and treating the “lower classes” as real people, all with good reason – as with most reformers, he was passionate because he’d been there.

But all that makes the movie sound “important” and as if it’s an arthouse movie that’s going to be preachy and dull, when what this movie is, most of all, is fun. It’s entertaining without preaching, exciting without a single cab chase, dramatic without being maudlin, witty without being over the top.

The cast is top-rate – all the performances are amazing. I literally can’t call out anyone over anyone else – yes, Stevens and Plummer are great, but so is the rest of the cast, even the child actors. In addition, the characters are three-dimensional, the screenplay excellent, the direction superb, the cinematography, costuming, and sets make you truly feel that you’re in London in the late 1800’s, and the score is perfect without being intrusive.

While it only came out a year ago, it deserves to be considered a Christmas classic that gets watched just like It’s A Wonderful Life and A Christmas Story do. The Man Who Invented Christmas is a thoroughly enjoyable movie, with laughs, pathos, excitement, wit, conflict, drama, and a happy ending that’s actually earned. It’s a “true” Christmas movie I honestly love.

Rating: 5 stars

Let us know what you think about our content in our webcast as well as our website. Please use the comment form below. Please be sure to read the Privacy / Terms and Conditions Of Use. Please remember to Play Nice.







Thanks for visiting. Let us know what you think.